Outstanding Unstructured Reality Program - 2019
- Nominee
- Shelly Tatro, Executive Producer
- Born This Way
- A&E
- Bunim/Murray Productions
Outstanding Unstructured Reality Program - 2018
- Nominee
- Shelly Tatro, Executive Producer
- Intervention
- A&E
- GRB Entertainment, Inc.
Outstanding Unstructured Reality Program - 2018
- Nominee
- Shelly Tatro, Executive Producer
- Born This Way
- A&E
- Bunim/Murray Productions
Outstanding Documentary or Nonfiction Special - 2017
- Nominee
- Shelly Tatro, Executive Producer
- L.A. Burning: The Riots 25 Years Later
- A&E
- Entertainment One Reality Productions, Inc. and Creature Films, Inc.
Outstanding Unstructured Reality Program - 2017
- Nominee
- Shelly Tatro, Executive Producer
- Born This Way
- A&E
- Bunim/Murray Productions
Outstanding Unstructured Reality Program - 2016
- Winner
- Shelly Tatro, Executive Producer
- Born This Way
- A&E
- Bunim/Murray Productions